Thou Hath Forget the Math

I often hear (today, most recently) “I shouldn’t eat that – it has ___ calories!”  Today’s comment was made in regards to a minimally processed granola bar that contained 150 calories.  This particular bar had few ingredients, most of which were nutrient-rich whole grains.  The bar had so much nutrition to offer – fiber, magnesium, zinc, etc. – but the benefits were overshadowed by focus on the caloric content.

Although when I first got my start as a newbie RDN, I was a pro at teaching patients to navigate the Nutrition Facts panel.  In fact, I taught whole classes and class series on how to interpret those numbers.  And, while I still find some relevance to at least noticing some of the nutrient values listed on the label, I find far more important information on the ingredients list.  So, I intend to encourage you to shift your focus to the ingredients of your food rather than just the numbers on the label.

You see, a food could have your arbitrarily defined “perfect” amount of calories; yet, it might be total crap.  Yep, crap.  I see decisions made by others every day solely based on math.  I see professional healthcare providers eating ridiculously nasty food (with little nutrition) in the name of calorie control (think TV dinners, “diet” drinks, etc.).  However, beautiful things can happen when you actually start to look at what is in the food you’re eating.

Here are some of my favorite “rules” to live by with regard to ingredients navigation at the grocery store:

  1. If you see that the list appears so long that you know you won’t have time to read it, that is a good indication you should put it back on the shelf and find something else.
  2. If you see “partially hydrogenated” or “hydrogenated,” choose something else.  No matter what the numbers on the label state, this food contains a particularly harmful type of dietary fat called trans fat.  Most foods containing hydrogenated oils aren’t that good for us anyway, if you really think about it.
  3. The list of ingredients should contain food.  In other words, you shouldn’t have to go online to Google the words to determine what they are; nor should you require a chemistry degree to crack the code.  Eat recognizable foods.
  4. Although we have all been taught that we will start on fire and die if we dare to eat a – gasp – processed food, the key is to determine the degree to which the food was altered [processed].  Foods in bags or boxes in the middle of the store aren’t inherently “bad.”  Just read the ingredients.  A box of crackers shouldn’t contain 7,000 ingredients; how about whole wheat, oil, and salt?  Fair?  Know what those things are?  Good.  Simple.
  5. Ingredients are listed by weight from most to least.  Therefore, if your ingredients label lists “sugar” as one of the first ingredients…yikes.  I’d suggest something else.  Beware that there are other disguise words for sugar, such as “brown rice syrup” or “dextrose,” among many others.  If you’re trying to reduce added sugar intake, keep an eye out for hidden sugars.
  6. Speaking of sugar, the Nutrition Facts panel lists “sugar” under “total carbohydrate.”  Sometimes this information can be misleading in the wrong hands.  For example, an 8 oz glass of plain cow’s milk contains about 12 grams of sugar.  This is not added sugar; rather, it is natural sugar.  They are not the same thing.  The trick to knowing if it is added versus natural is to read the ingredients!  The ingredients will include sugar, or some disguised form of sugar, if it is added.  Sometimes the food will contain added and natural sugars.  Things get really crazy then…


Here is the absolute bottom line summary:  

  • If your food is high in calories, and also high in nutrition (contains ample whole vegetables, whole fruits, whole grains, nuts, seeds, legumes, vitamins, minerals, etc.), be mindful of the amount you are consuming and listen to hunger/fullness cues.
  • If your food is high in calories, and low in nutrition (i.e. cookies, candy, etc.), consider an alternative that will provide you with a vitamin or mineral or two instead.  Otherwise, be very, very careful with the amount you consume.  Low-nutrition foods are not filling, and lead to a cascade of triggers for overeating.
  • If your food is low in calories, and high in nutrition, GREAT!  (think leafy greens, carrots, peppers, tomatoes, etc.)  EAT ALL YOU WANT.
  • If your food is low in calories, and low in nutrition (think diet soda, TV dinners, sugar-free candy), then it isn’t helpful.  It really isn’t – it’s fake food.  Gross.  Stop it.
  • Count nutrients, not calories.  Odds are, if you’re focusing on eating whole vegetables, whole fruits, whole grains, lean proteins, nuts, seeds, legumes, etc., you’re going to fill up your belly long before you eat too many calories (usually).


Eat food. Not too much. Mostly plants.

– Michael Pollen

10 thoughts on “Thou Hath Forget the Math

  1. […] Try to look at the big picture with nutrition. It will take you further than counting anything… […]


  2. […] “how do I eat more vegetables,” often the calories, fat, salt, and all those other dreaded numbers typically fall right into […]


  3. […] note that my “recipe” does not contain specific measurements or nutrition stats. I tend to not focus on numbers of any kind when it comes to eating; rather, I focus on finding ways to include as much nutrition into my meal […]


  4. […] Stop counting stuff. Stop obsessing over nutrients and focus on FOODS. Stop dieting. Stop buying packets of crap to put […]


  5. […] soy sauce is not suddenly “healthy.”  However, please don’t lose sleep over counting anything, including sodium or […]


  6. […] some whole grains, some healthy fats, and some protein-rich foods.  However, the old adage “calories in versus calories out” is misleading.  Many factors influence weight loss or gain.  Certain hormones are involved […]


  7. […] some really, really healthy foods from the dreaded center of the store. The INGREDIENTS list (not the numbers, but actually what is in your food) should become your best friend if you desire success with […]


  8. […] density superior to the number of calories.  Read more on the important aspects of nutrition math here.)  Anyway, if your bread contains 5 grams of fiber per slice, a regular ol’ sandwich would then […]


  9. […] keeps a “snack” a snack and not a meal?  The size.  I am an adamant non-numbers practitioner when it comes to nutrition, but IF we were counting, a snack’s caloric content would […]


  10. […] some people are insistent on counting calories and macros and all sorts of numbers, you’re not going to find that here.  Why?  Because healthy […]


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s